The Poison Widow of Whitewater: Unraveling a Haunted Tale

8/7/20241 min read

Introduction

Hey, I'm Sam!

Hi, I'm Amber! And we're the Crude Twins! Welcome to our chaos. Welcome back, Crude Twins fam; we're so glad you're here. And if you're new, welcome! We're so happy you're here as well.

Today's minisode is a haunted one, focusing on the notorious tale of the Poison Widow located in Whitewater, Wisconsin. This eerie story has captivated the minds of locals and history enthusiasts such as ourselves. So, let's dive in!

The Story of the Poison Widow

The story dates back to the early 20th century, centering on a farm just outside of Whitewater. The farm was owned by Edward and Myrtle Schaude. To help with finances, the couple boarded rooms to students attending a nearby school. However, this seemingly peaceful arrangement took a dark turn when Myrtle fell in love with one of the students, Ernst.

Allegedly, on March 18, 1922, Myrtle slipped poison into her husband's food, leading to his untimely demise. The scandal rocked the community, with Myrtle becoming infamously known as the Poison Widow. To this day, her motives and actions remain shrouded in mystery, sparking endless speculation and fascination.

The Lack of Information

Despite being a well-known tale, there is surprisingly little documented information available about Myrtle Schaude and her nefarious deed. The lack of concrete evidence has only fueled the legend, adding to its allure. As we researched this tale, we were startled by the limited resources that provided in-depth details. This scarcity leaves many questions unanswered, contributing to the story’s mystique.

Final Thoughts

The story of the Poison Widow is a haunting chapter in the history of Whitewater, Wisconsin. It highlights how real-life events often transcend into folklore, captivating generations. Even though information is sparse, the story continues to be a point of intrigue and discussion.

Thank you for joining us in exploring this enigmatic story. Stay tuned for more chaotic yet enlightening tales! Until next time, this has been the Crude Twins.